Document Type : Original Article


1 PhD student, Department of Curriculum Planning, Tabriz Branch, Islamic Azad University of Tabriz, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Curriculum Studies, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran.

3 Associate Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Tabriz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tabriz, Iran



Purpose: Due to the importance of descriptive evaluation in elementary school, the present study was conducted with the aim of designing and validating of academic achievement evaluation pattern in elementary schools multi-grade classes.
Methodology: The present study in terms of time was cross-sectional, in terms of purpose was applied and in terms of implementation method was qualitative. The research population was university experts and managers primary education staff of country in 2021 year. The research sample was 15 people according to the theoretical saturation principle who after examining the inclusion criteria were selected by purposive sampling method. The research tool was a semi-structured interview and data were analyzed by coding method in MAXQDA software.
Findings: Findings showed that the academic achievement evaluation pattern in elementary schools multi-grade classes has 306 indicators and 41 components in 6 categories of goals and approaches (with 11 components such as comprehensive evaluation and its application to life, descriptive evaluation in all areas, descriptive evaluation qualification with reported structure change and process-based qualitative evaluation with structuralist approach), contextual (with 4 components of management equipment implementation of evaluation of multi-grade classes, rationalization of executive infrastructures with emphasis on reducing density in multi-grade classes, quality of teaching and teacher evaluation methods and culture and dissemination of descriptive evaluation factors), input (with 5 components of qualitative evaluation tools, paying attention to the educational expectations of multi-grade classes, performing descriptive evaluation in all teaching stages, adaptation of multi-grade curriculum with descriptive evaluation and coordination of weekly program with learning roadmap), process (with 13 components such as increasing confidence, calmness, satisfaction and self-esteem, reducing the anxiety of multi-level students, quality of criteria in the report card, variety of self-assessment and peer assessment and parenting assessment tools and emphasizing to group learning of multi-grade students), output (with 5 components of participatory decision making for basic promotion, quality of reporting and report card of student, validity, reliability and testability of multi-level descriptive evaluation, continuous learning with diverse feedback and multi-dimensional quality the descriptive evaluation with qualitative feedback) and outcome (with 3 components of annual analysis of the findings of descriptive evaluation, analysis of the findings of descriptive evaluation longitudinally and analysis of the consequences of descriptive evaluation). Also, the content validity ratio of 0.90 and the content validity index of 0.92 according to the experts' opinion indicated the appropriate validity of the academic achievement evaluation pattern in elementary schools multi-grade classes.
Conclusion: According to the results of this study, planning is necessary to the academic achievement evaluation pattern in elementary schools multi-grade classes


Azizi Mahmoodabad M, Nili MR. (2019). The evaluation of elementary school math curriculum: Proposing a model. New Thoughts on Education, 15(2): 123-146. (In Persian)
Bashiri Haddadan G, Mahmoodi F, Rezapoor Y, Adib Y. (2016). Describing the experience and perception of teachers and experts from education in multi-grade classes of primary schools in rural areas of Kalibar. Teaching and Learning Research, 12(2): 107-120. (In Persian)
Beigi N, Rezazadeh Bahadoran HR, Khosravi Babadi A, Pooshne K. (2021). Design and field validation of the model for implementing evaluation of academic achievement at elementary school. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 16(62): 83-110. (In Persian)
Buaraphan K, Inrit B, Kochasila W. (2018). Current policy and practice concerning multigrade teaching in Thailand. Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences, 39(3): 496-501.
Checchi D, De Paola M. (2018). The effect of multigrade classes on cognitive and non- cognitive skills. Causal evidence exploiting minimum class size rules in Italy. Economics of Education Review, 67: 235-253.
Chua H, Lee S, Fulmer GW. (2017). Action research on the effect of descriptive and evaluative feedback order on student learning in a specialized mathematics and science secondary school. Asia Pacific Science Education, 3(4): 1-22.
Ebrahimpour Koumleh S, Naderi E, Seif Naraghi M. (2017). The role of problem solving skills in emergence of healthy and positive behaviors: Development and evaluation of an optimal model for social studies for primary school  curriculum. Payesh, 16(1): 39-51. (In Persian)
Entehaei Arani A, Vasefian F, Hassani M, Gholtash A. (2021). Elementary teachers' living experiences regarding the functions of descriptive (qualitative) evaluation. Quarterly Journal of Training in Police Sciences, 9(24): 99-542. (In Persian)
Entehayi Arani A, Hasani M, Shekari A. (2015). The study of the feedback of the teachers, administering the descriptive-quantitative evaluation. Research in Curriculum Planning, 11(16): 119-131. (In Persian)
Faisal R, Shinwari L, Mateen H. (2016). Evaluation of the academic achievement of rural versus urban undergraduate medical students in pharmacology examinations. Asian Pacific Journal of Reproduction, 5(4): 317-320.
Fazlikhani M. (2014). Designing and validating a qualitative evaluation model for assessing students’ science achievement in the first grade of junior high school. Quarterly Journal of Family and Research, 11(1): 35-54. (In Persian)
Gholtash A, Ojinejad AR, Dehghan Mongabadi AR. (2015). The pathology of descriptive evaluation model in order to present an appropriate model for elementary levels. Quarterly Journal of Research in School and Virtual Learning, 3(10): 7-16. (In Persian)
Heuvel-Panhuizen MV, Sangari AA, Veldhuis M. (2021). Teachers’ use of descriptive assessment in primary school mathematics education in Iran. Education Sciences, 11(3): 1-23.
Karimi MS, Ghafoori Kh. (2018). The limitations and benefits of multi-grade classes based on multi-grade classes teachers' lived experiences. Journal of Teacher's Professional Development, 3(2): 59-74. (In Persian)
Khakzad F, Dehghani M, Razi J. (2016). Comparison of implicit learning and academic achievement in multiple grade classes in primary schools. Applied Psychological Research Quarterly, 7(1): 41-56. (In Persian)
Kim M. (2020). Primary school size and learning achievement Senegal: Testing the quantity-quality trade off. International Journal of Educational Development, 77: 78-92.
Lerman DC, Luck KM, Smothermon S, Et al. (2020). Training of paraprofessionals by their classroom teachers: A descriptive evaluation of pyramidal training outcomes. Journal of Behavioral Education, 29(4): 675-698.
Meng F, Chu D, Li K, Zhou X. (2019). Multiple-class multidimensional knapsack optimisation problem and its solution approaches. Knowledge-Based-Systems, 166: 1-17.
Mirzamohammadi MH. (2009). A model for evaluation of student achievement in arts related technical vocational fields of study based on a comparative research findings. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 5(17): 153-173. (In Persian)
Mortazavizadeh SH, Nili MR, Nasr Isfahani AR, Hassani M. (2018). Analysis of teachers' views about the problems of project descriptive qualitative evaluation in multigrade classrooms and providing solutions to eliminate them. Research in Curriculum Planning, 15(30): 80-93. (In Persian)
Nikolic N, Antonijevic R. (2013). Class teacher's perception of descriptive evaluation. Research in Pedagogy, 3(2): 31-47.
Piri M, Shahi R. (2016). Effects of multi-media teaching on academic engagement of sixth grade learners of nomadic multi-grade classes in science course. Technology of Education Journal, 11(1): 11-19. (In Persian)
Seyyed Kalan SM, Heidari. (2021). Evaluating the management of multi-grade elementary school classrooms from the perspective of educational leaders. Pouyesh Journal in Teaching Educational Sciences and Counseling, 6(13): 2-18. (In Persian)
Wanga M, Dengb X, Dua X. (2017). Harsh parenting and academic achievement in Chinese adolescents: Potential mediating roles of effortful control and classroom engagement. Journal of School Psychology, 5(2): 1-15.
Zahed Babelan A, Farajollahi M, Hamrang M. (2013). Effective factors in applying descriptive evaluation from primary school teachers’ point of view. Technology of Education Journal, 6(4): 267-276. (In Persian).